A scorecard is a mathematical model that is used to predict a certain outcome (for example the probability of default). The information used in a scorecard can vary, but common fields include demographic characteristics (e.g. age of the applicant, number of dependants, time spent in the current job) and credit bureau data (e.g. number of personal loans registered to applicant, worst arrears status on all account in the last 6 months).
Scorecards are used throughout developed and many developing credit markets to assist risk managers to determine with which customers to do business.
Scorecards are made up of a number of characteristics, typically 7-15. These characteristics represent “questions”. The answers to these questions are known as attributes. For example “How old are you?” would be the characteristic and “28” might be the attribute. The weighting is the “score” assigned to the attribute. Typically the higher the score the lower the risk.
Characteristic | Attribute | Weighting | |
Age of applicant | 18-25 | 10 | |
26-45 | 20 | ||
46+ | 30 | + | |
Number of dependants | 0 | 25 | |
1-3 | 15 | + | |
4+ | 5 | ||
TOTAL SCORE | 45 |
There are 2 characteristics that appear in this simplified scorecard: “Age of applicant” and “Number of dependants”. Each applicant will be grouped into an attribute group under each characteristic and each attribute will be assigned a weighting. For example, Lindsay Loan is 48 (so she gets assigned under the 3rd attribute group for age, namely “46+”). She has 3 children so she falls under the 1-3 dependant attribute group. Next to each attribute group she receives the scores 30 and 15 respectively. Her total score is therefore 30+15=45.
Scorecards typically have cut-offs. Above the cut-off would represent acceptable risk and below the cut-off unacceptable risk. If the cut-off in our above example is 33 then Lindsay would be approved.
Let’s take another 2 applicants.
Age | Dependants | |
Lindsay Loan | 48 | 3 |
Johnny Debt | 23 | 1 |
William Default | 33 | 0 |
The second applicant, Johnny Debt would get 10 points for “Age” and 15 points for dependants, resulting in a total score of 25. Johnny would be declined by the scorecard. The third applicant Nick would receive scores of 20 and 25 totalling 45 points. Nick would be accepted. The scores could be represented on the following grid with the coloured squares representing the respective scores of the applicants in the examples (the red numbers being the scores below the cut-off):
A simple example of a 2 characteristics scorecard is displayed below:
Dependants | |||||
pts | 25 | 15 | 5 | ||
pts | group | 0 | 1-3 | 4+ | |
Age | 10 | 18-25 | 35 | 25 | 15 |
20 | 26-45 | 45 | 35 | 25 | |
30 | 46+ | 55 | 45 | 35 |
Different Scorecards
Scorecards are used to predict a variety of different outcomes including:
- A new applicant defaulting
- An existing loan defaulting
- A customer in arrears making a successful payment
- A customer spending more on her credit card in the next 6 months
- A consumer responding to a targeted marketing campaign
- A customer lapsing on an insurance premium
- A customer closing their account
- A customer skipping the country
- A customer moving to a competitor
- A customer having an insurance claim
All these models are built in a similar way, but with different input data and outcome predictors.